Capture one vs lightroom12/29/2023 ![]() ![]() Read on to see exactly when you might prefer one photo editor over the other. Having both programs means that every potential photography situation is catered for, but this obviously comes at some expense. I have found that Capture One and Lightroom often complement each other, with one being preferable in situations where the other doesn’t perform as well. This article covers all of the major pros and cons of each, plus the similarities and differences that apply in the real-world to photographers like ourselves. With the increasing popularity of Capture One over the last few years, many photographers are wondering whether they should switch to Capture 1 from Lightroom, or whether it would benefit them to use both together. ![]() Lightroom is better for those looking for a wide range of editing tools, those who value photo organization, or those who will be finishing their editing in Photoshop or who will be printing directly from their editor.It is great at editing photos, supports a very wide range of cameras and lenses, and is equally good at. There is definitely no question regarding the abilities of this photo editing software. Adobe’s Lightroom has been the software of choice for photographers for a long time now. Capture One is better for professional / studio photographers or those who demand high-end retouching in their photo editing program, particularly if you use Fujifilm, Sony or Nikon cameras. Capture One vs Lightroom in 2022 Photo Editing Software.But the Phase One support folk are on the ball and over the last year or so it is clear that engineering are working hard on improving the software.If you don’t have time to read the full article, then when comparing Capture One vs Lightroom: Here is an example of processing an E-M5 high-ISO file in C1 and LR, where LR completely blows out the red channels due to the default saturation and Adobe Standard colour profile pushing the red tones far outside of the output sRGB space.Īfter processing a ton of examples like this from several different cameras, I think that I like C1's colour and UI better, while preferring LRs key-wording and indexing.Ĭ1 has quite a lot of quirks (mostly due to terminology) and bugs (for me, the inability to open 16 bit grayscale TIFF film scans.). The differences are often camera specific, but I found that Lightroom tends to over-saturate its reds compared to C1. I have just switched to C1P from LR6, and wrote a long-ish review of the pros and cons ( here). Have you picked the Whitebalance from the same point on the 2 images? If not, you cannot compare them directly, other than concluding that LR and CO take different approaches to their respective defaults. a still life default, a food default, a portrait default). Once you get used to the basics consider a training class where you'll learn more advanced workflows like having multiple "defaults" which you can rapidly change between by keyboard shortcut depending on the subject matter (e.g. just turn the dials once and forget about it. It's like buying a set of really nice speakers and complaining that they don't boost the treble and bass as much out-of-the-box compared to a low-end set of speakers. Whether the universal-default-as-installed numbers suit you is more or less a crap shoot. The improvement in quality going from LR to C1 is in things like color discrimination (showing two slightly different colors as being different), color linearity (showing the same hue in a contrasty-light subject from shadow to highlight), detail extraction (pixel quality of detail, regardless of sharpening especially when using a good camera like a Phase One or Leaf back where there is more detail that can be extracted) etc. They will become the new "default" used any time a raw is seen for the first time. You'll never have to touch those controls again when importing or shooting tethered, unless you want to make further changes. There is no right or wrong in color, unless you are doing art reproduction or scientific studies.įind settings that suit your aesthetics and the needs of your clients, then use the in the top right of any given tool and select to save those as defaults. I double checked and as far as I can tell C1 is using the correct camera profile.įor those of you that have used both - do these results make sense? Could I be doing something wrong? I understand that I can adjust everything to my hearts content from here, but it doesn't seem worth switching over to C1 if LR looks better out of the box. This is the untouched LR import (from tethered capture):Īnd this is the untouched C1 import (from card): So I downloaded a trail of C1, ran a quick test, and saw the exact opposite (pardon the messy looking sandwiches): C1 also seemed to emphasize the reds a bit. I saw some pretty impressive side-by-sides: compared to LR, C1's unprocessed color corrects were richer, typically more saturated, had more pop. I've been considering switching from Lightroom to Capture One after reading many rave reviews on C1's superior color management out of the box.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |